The Fiery Furnaces - Remember

The Fiery Furnaces are a band of absolutes. They are always quirky. They are always talented. The are always unique. And they are NEVER normal. Any sense of normality is completely thrown out the window on this "live" album.

One of the most striking things about this presentation is how "un-live" the album really is. The Fiery Furnaces are famous for reworking every minute detail of even their most staple songs in a live setting. And anyone familiar with even a portion of their back catalogue can attest that there is seldom need to rework, each new track brings a fresh and unique sound. This just doesn't seem enough for Matt and Eleanor Friedberger, who have enough new and strange ideas kicking around that reusing perfectly good album sounds just seems like a waste of new, uncharted ones.

And so it fits that using the typical sounds and experiences of a single show waste the sounds that can be created by a meshing and mixing of many shows. Some of the longer songs include sections from seperate locations, even seperate backing bands, and the recording volume and quality are all over the place. It seems that more work went into making this album sound anything but live than went into many of the reimaginings present on it.

The end result plays like a pick and choose of medleys and might-have-beens, each song flowing into the next daring you to take a breath and risk missing a beat. Pretty daring for an album that carries a disclaimer: "Do not attempt to listen to all at once." Sometimes things work better than others, of course, with the Bitter Tea medley being the absolute standout, in pacing and musical brilliance. But the album begs so many questions of the listener, such as: why on a live album bent on not sounding live, would the second track contain a very noticable vocal flub? Why, in all their editing, did they find it fitting to leave in a testament to the risks of performance?

I don't have the answers, but the questions make the music all the more interesting. The winning formula here is one that The Fiery Furnaces seem to have held forever: music that sounds like nothing else. For a collection of old songs, this album plays like a breath of fresh air, inhaling pure talent and exhaling imagination.

Album Hightlights: "Bitter Tea" right through "Bitter Tea (Reprise)"

Further Listening: Blueberry Boat, Bitter Tea